Can Hypnotherapy Make You Do Things Against Your Will?

Research has not shown hypnotherapy making you do things against your will. In clinical hypnotherapy you stay aware and decide whether to act on each suggestion.

The best-known experiment found that people who were not hypnotised did the same things as hypnotised participants.

What did you picture the last time you heard the word hypnosis?

Hypnosis carries a reputation shaped by entertainment, where it is shown as a form of remote control. The real risks are narrower and worth knowing: heightened responsiveness to suggestion, and memories that feel vivid but may be inaccurate.

Antique pocket watch hanging from a chain, a classic image of hypnosis

What Hypnosis Is, According to Psychologists

Hypnosis is a state of focused attention and reduced peripheral awareness that comes with an enhanced capacity to respond to suggestion. That is the definition published by Elkins and colleagues in 2015 for Division 30 of the American Psychological Association. It describes a focused, awake state. It does not describe sleep or unconsciousness.

The same body defines hypnotherapy as the use of hypnosis in the treatment of a medical or psychological disorder or concern. A clinician guides an induction. The clinician then offers suggestions towards a change the client wants. Afik Faerman, a Division 30 officer, summed up the division of labour in the American Psychological Association’s Monitor on Psychology. The facilitator guides, but “it’s up to that person to act on my suggestions.”

Experts still debate whether hypnosis is a distinct altered state or a shift in attention. Both camps agree that it involves a special kind of focused attention that opens people up to suggestion.

Focused is not the same as asleep.

What the Research Found When It Tested Control

Orne and Evans’s 1965 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology is the best-known test of whether hypnosis can compel behaviour. It found that people who were not hypnotised did the same things. Hypnotised participants were willing to handle a venomous snake and throw what looked like acid at an assistant. So were people pretending to be hypnotised.

The setup was safe. A concealed pane of glass protected the participants’ hands from the snake. The acid was swapped for a harmless coloured solution before it was thrown. Five of the six hypnotised participants carried out every task. All six simulators, who had shown no hypnotic response, attempted the tasks at least as readily. In a waking group told they were controls, five of six attempted both acid tasks.

Orne and Evans concluded that participants saw the tasks as legitimate requests within a research setting. They said they were convinced the activities were safe because responsible scientists were running the study. The authors were careful. The study does not answer whether antisocial behaviour can be elicited under hypnosis. What it showed is that this kind of demonstration cannot by itself be credited to hypnosis. Participants who were not hypnotised behaved the same way.

One more detail matters. When the hypnotised participants returned a day later and were asked awake, most refused. They said that under hypnosis they felt more passive and less concerned about consequences. Hypnosis may lower hesitation, and trust in the people running the session shapes what a person will do. The study is also old and small, with six people per group.

Why Hypnosis Can Feel Like Losing Control

Hypnotic responses often feel automatic. That sense of involuntariness is where the idea of lost control comes from. Lynn, Laurence and Kirsch’s 2015 review in the American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis treats the experience of involuntariness as one of the hallmarks of hypnosis. They link it to social, cognitive and neurophysiological variables. Feeling that something happens by itself differs from being unable to refuse it.

Amanda Barnier is a cognitive scientist who has studied hypnosis for decades. She told the Monitor that hypnosis changes a person’s sense of authorship, so that the effort becomes external to them. In her view this makes change easier to start.

Where Hypnosis Does Carry Real Risk

The genuine concerns about hypnosis are memory and suggestibility, and neither involves loss of free will. A 1985 report in JAMA looked at using hypnosis to refresh the memories of witnesses and victims. It found that recollections obtained during hypnosis can involve confabulations and pseudomemories. They appear to be less reliable than nonhypnotic recall. The report is 41 years old and concerned forensic interviewing. It is a caution rather than a measure of clinical practice today.

A memory that surfaces under hypnosis can feel vivid and still be inaccurate. Treat it as the client’s experience, not as proof of what happened. Hypnosis is a poor tool for establishing facts.

Suggestibility matters most after trauma. A 2022 meta-analysis by Wieder, Brown, Thompson and Terhune pooled 20 datasets. It found higher hypnotic suggestibility than controls in dissociative disorders, trauma- and stressor-related disorders and functional neurological disorder (Hedges’s g of 0.92, falling to 0.57 after correction for publication bias). That is an association, not proof that hypnosis causes those conditions. It is a reason to take a clinical history first. Terhune has called high hypnotisability a “double-edged sword” in the Monitor.

Reported physical and psychological harm is low in the research that exists. A 2016 review in Deutsches Ärzteblatt International by Häuser and colleagues covered two meta-analyses. Both showed no difference between hypnosis and control treatment for side effects and safety in medical procedures. Bollinger’s 2018 analysis of registered trials found no serious adverse events likely attributable to hypnosis. It found a 0.47% rate of other adverse events.

Many trials did not report adverse events. All of them treated medical conditions rather than psychiatric ones. The figures say little about hypnosis used for anxiety or trauma.

Common Fears Compared With What the Evidence Shows

Each common fear about hypnotherapy maps onto a specific piece of research. The evidence supports some fears only partly. The table sets each fear beside what the sources found and how far that finding can be trusted. That separates the reasonable concerns from the myths.

Common fearWhat the sources foundHow far it goes
I will do things I would refuse awakeOrne and Evans (1965): non-hypnotised and simulating participants complied as readily as hypnotised onesResearch has not shown it; one small, old experiment, and the authors call the question open
I will be unconscious and not know what is happeningDivision 30 defines hypnosis as focused attention with reduced peripheral awareness; The Reset Room describes clients as fully awareA definition and a clinical description, not a trial result
Hypnosis will pull out the truth about my pastCouncil on Scientific Affairs (1985, a forensic report): hypnotic recall can include confabulations and is less reliable than ordinary recallSupported: the risk is inaccurate memory
Hypnotherapy is dangerousHäuser (2016) and Bollinger (2018) found low rates of reported harmLimited: mostly medical procedures, with gaps in adverse-event reporting

What Most People Get Wrong About Hypnotherapy Safety

Most mistakes about hypnotherapy safety come from the stage-show picture. It points attention at the wrong risk and away from memory, suggestibility and the practitioner’s background. Each pitfall below is paired with the finding that explains it, so you can judge how much weight it deserves. These five are worth avoiding before you book:

  • Assuming trance means unconsciousness. The definition describes focused attention and reduced peripheral awareness.
  • Trusting a vivid memory from a session. Hypnotic recall was found to be less reliable than ordinary recall in the 1985 report.
  • Applying low harm rates to every use of hypnosis. The trials behind them treated medical conditions, not psychiatric ones.
  • Skipping a health and trauma history. Suggestibility is higher in dissociative and trauma-related conditions.
  • Treating hypnotherapy as a stand-alone treatment. Gary Elkins told the Monitor that hypnosis is not a primary intervention and works as an adjunct to psychotherapy.

What a Hypnotherapy Session at The Reset Room Involves

Clinical hypnotherapy at The Reset Room in Houghton Estate, Johannesburg, is delivered by Dr Safeera Kholvadia, a medical doctor. The practice’s clinical hypnotherapy page describes a guided session of 90 to 120 minutes in which the client stays aware throughout. The page says a client cannot be made to do or say anything against their will. That is consistent with, but not proven by, the research above.

Most clients begin with an initial consultation of 60 to 90 minutes, where the approach is assessed. Hypnotherapy usually follows inside the four-session ARC Integration Phase, in session three. By then earlier sessions have worked on regulating the nervous system. A stand-alone session may be arranged for specific presentations. The client takes home a personalised recording for the following days.

Questions to Ask Before a First Session

A good first conversation answers practical questions about training, control and next steps before any induction begins. These five questions help you judge a hypnotherapist of any kind. A clear, unhurried answer to each is a reasonable thing to expect from anyone offering the work.

  • What is your training and professional background, and who do you answer to?
  • How will I stop or decline a suggestion during a session?
  • What happens if a distressing memory surfaces?
  • How do you treat memories that come up, as experience or as fact?
  • How does this fit alongside my doctor’s care and any other therapy?

Ask about clinical hypnotherapy

Doctor-led consultation, with the approach assessed before any session.
The Reset Room, Houghton Estate, Johannesburg.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a hypnotherapist make you do something you don’t want to do?

Research has not shown hypnosis making people do things they would refuse awake. In Orne and Evans’s 1965 experiment, people who were not hypnotised did the same things as hypnotised participants. In clinical hypnotherapy you stay aware, and it is up to you whether to act on any suggestion.

Can hypnosis make you reveal secrets or say things you don’t want to?

Research has not shown hypnosis working as a truth serum. A 1985 JAMA report on forensic hypnosis found that recollections obtained during hypnosis can include confabulations and appear less reliable than ordinary recall. In clinical hypnotherapy you stay aware and decide what you say.

Will you be unconscious during hypnotherapy?

Hypnosis is a state of focused attention with reduced peripheral awareness, according to the American Psychological Association’s Division 30 definition. It is not unconsciousness. At The Reset Room, clients stay fully aware during a guided session, which lasts 90 to 120 minutes.

Is hypnotherapy safe?

Reported harm from hypnosis is low in the research that exists. A 2018 analysis of registered trials found no serious adverse events likely attributable to hypnosis, though many trials did not report adverse events and none treated psychiatric conditions. A health and trauma history before starting matters.

Who should be careful about hypnotherapy?

People with a history of trauma or a dissociative condition should tell their practitioner and their doctor before starting. A 2022 meta-analysis found higher hypnotic suggestibility in dissociative, trauma- and stressor-related disorders and functional neurological disorder (Hedges’s g of 0.92). That is an association, and a reason for a proper clinical history first.

Disclaimer. General health information, not medical advice. Hypnotherapy is a complementary approach and does not replace medical or psychological care. If you have a history of trauma or a dissociative condition, tell your practitioner and your doctor before starting.

Scroll to Top